The crisis in West Midlands Police following the controversial ban on Maccabi Tel Aviv fans from a match against Aston Villa has escalated further.

The Home Secretary, Shabana Mahmood, says she has lost confidence in Chief Constable Craig Guildford, following a damning report citing leadership failures, confirmation bias, and the misuse of AI-generated intelligence.

The inspectorate’s report found confirmation bias, which means focusing and relying on information that supports their existing view, and overlooking evidence that challenges it, misleading public statements, and the use of false intelligence generated by AI evidence was exaggerated and in some cases simply untrue.

Parliament was misled. Key communities were not properly engaged. This scandal goes to the heart of a problem running through the police.

To examine this, we must ask, what is policing for? It is to enforce the law and protect the public on the basis of evidence with public consent, it is part of the nation, not above or outside the communities that are policed.

We learn that AI was misused to act as intelligence and relied upon. This is a failure of leadership. Tools and technology do not make decisions. It is the people using them that must be held accountable.

And what about public safety – the principle on which the ban was imposed? The report shows threats to Israeli fans were downplayed while threats from them to other communities were exaggerated.

That is not how policing should be conducted. The police are there to protect all citizens, all groups, and all communities regardless of race, colour or creed. The decision to ban Maccabi Tel Aviv fans now reeks of antisemitism.

Now the Home Secretary says she has no confidence in police Chief Constable Guildford, which means he will have to leave.

While the police may have operational independence, they need the confidence of the political nation.

Without that they have no legitimacy to operate.

Unfortunately the problem does not end with the West Midlands police – it is indicative of a wider problem of political issues and culture wars influencing the decisions of police authorities.

Policing depends on consent and on honesty, and misjudgement and malpractice require consequences.